U.S. President Donald Trump recently made a bold statement claiming that the BRICS group has broken apart. This has sparked debates about the actual state of BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa) and whether Trump’s assertion holds any truth. But is BRICS really falling apart, or is this just political rhetoric? Let’s analyze the situation in detail, especially from India’s perspective.
What Did Donald Trump Say About BRICS?
During a recent public appearance, Donald Trump confidently declared that the BRICS group had “broken up.” He stated that after he threatened BRICS countries with a 150% tariff, the alliance collapsed. His statement suggested that BRICS was no longer functioning as a powerful economic group and that its members had abandoned their plans to challenge the dominance of the U.S. dollar.
Trump said:
“BRICS broke up. I haven’t heard from them. I told them if they do anything against the dollar, there will be 150% tariffs. They got scared and backed off.”
His remarks were aimed at his voter base in the U.S., portraying himself as a leader whose tough economic policies successfully weakened BRICS. However, is there any truth to his claims? Let’s examine the current state of BRICS to see if it has truly disintegrated.
The Current Status of BRICS: Is It Really Falling Apart?
Contrary to Trump’s claims, the reality is quite different. Rather than breaking up, BRICS is expanding and strengthening.
- BRICS Expansion:
- New members have joined BRICS: In 2023, BRICS expanded by inviting Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE as new members.
- Indonesia is set to become the 10th member in 2024, further strengthening the alliance.
- More countries have expressed interest in joining BRICS, indicating its growing influence.
- BRICS Currency Plans Are No Longer a Priority:
- While there were discussions about a common BRICS currency in the past, this idea has faded away.
- India and Russia have clearly stated that there are no plans for a unified BRICS currency.
- Indian Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal recently emphasized that India does not see any possibility of sharing a currency with China.
- BRICS Remains a Strong Economic Bloc:
- The combined GDP of BRICS nations is larger than that of the G7 (the group of major Western economies).
- BRICS members continue to trade in local currencies, reducing their dependence on the U.S. dollar.
- Despite U.S. sanctions and economic pressures, BRICS nations are actively increasing cooperation in trade, energy, and geopolitics.
- Upcoming BRICS Summit in 2024:
- The 2024 BRICS Summit will be held in Brazil, proving that the group is still active.
- Topics such as economic partnerships, digital payments, and expansion strategies will be discussed.
Given these facts, there is no evidence to support Trump’s claim that BRICS has broken apart. On the contrary, the group is evolving into a larger and more influential economic alliance.
India’s Perspective on BRICS and Trump’s Statement
India plays a crucial role in BRICS and has maintained a balanced approach in global geopolitics. Here’s how India views the current situation:
- India Sees BRICS as an Opportunity, Not a Rivalry
- Unlike China and Russia, which see BRICS as a challenge to the West, India views BRICS as a platform for economic cooperation rather than confrontation with the U.S.
- India has not supported the idea of de-dollarization, ensuring that BRICS remains a practical economic alliance rather than an anti-West bloc.
- India’s Independent Stance
- India has always maintained a non-aligned foreign policy, balancing relations with the U.S., Europe, Russia, and China.
- While India cooperates with BRICS, it is also a key member of U.S.-led alliances like the QUAD (with the U.S., Japan, and Australia).
- This means India does not see BRICS as a tool to challenge the U.S. but rather as a way to expand economic and diplomatic influence.
- India’s Trade Relations With the U.S. and BRICS
- The U.S. is India’s largest trading partner, and strong economic ties between the two nations continue despite BRICS.
- India has not fully adopted the BRICS local currency trade model. Instead, it prefers bilateral trade agreements that suit its economic interests.
- India will not support any BRICS move that harms its economic relations with the U.S.
- India Rejects the BRICS Currency Idea
- India has made it clear that it will not share a currency with China, as it could lead to economic dependence.
- Indian policymakers believe that a BRICS currency would not be practical due to differences in economic policies among member nations.
- This directly contradicts Trump’s claim that BRICS was ever a major threat to the U.S. dollar.
- India’s Role in BRICS Expansion
- India supported BRICS expansion but ensured that new members align with its strategic goals.
- India played a key role in including the UAE and Saudi Arabia, strengthening its ties with Middle Eastern economies.
- This expansion benefits India’s trade and diplomatic reach, showing that BRICS remains important for India’s global ambitions.
Why Did Trump Claim That BRICS Has Broken?
Donald Trump’s statement about BRICS breaking apart appears to be political rhetoric aimed at boosting his image among American voters.
- U.S. Elections & Campaign Strategy
- Trump is running for the 2024 U.S. Presidential election.
- He wants to showcase himself as a strong leader who weakened BRICS and protected the U.S. economy.
- His claims are not based on facts but are meant to appeal to his supporters.
- Trump’s Lack of Knowledge About BRICS
- In the same speech, Trump admitted that he did not even know China was a BRICS member.
- He has made similar factual errors in the past, raising doubts about his understanding of global economic alliances.
- Inflation & Tariffs in the U.S.
- Trump’s 150% tariff threat is unrealistic and would likely harm the U.S. economy more than BRICS nations.
- If Trump imposes such tariffs, inflation in the U.S. will rise sharply, leading to increased costs for American consumers.
- U.S. Opposition to BRICS
- The U.S. has long viewed BRICS as a challenge to its economic dominance.
- Western countries fear that BRICS could weaken the influence of the U.S. dollar in global trade.
- Trump’s statement is likely an attempt to downplay the growing power of BRICS.
Final Thoughts
Trump’s statement that “BRICS has broken” is not based on reality. Instead:
- BRICS is expanding, with new members like Indonesia joining soon.
- India continues to play a major role, balancing BRICS with its global interests.
- There are no plans for a common BRICS currency, but trade in local currencies is increasing.
- The U.S. cannot stop BRICS’ growth through tariffs or sanctions.
- The upcoming BRICS Summit in Brazil in 2024 proves that the group is still active.
India, as a rising global power, will ensure that BRICS remains a platform for economic growth rather than an anti-U.S. alliance. While Trump’s claim serves his election campaign, the actual developments within BRICS tell a very different story—one of resilience, expansion, and strategic growth.
What Do You Think?
Do you believe Trump’s claim that BRICS has broken apart? Or do you think BRICS will continue to grow as a global economic force? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!
🚀 Stay tuned for more updates on global affairs, BRICS developments, and India’s role in global politics!
Also Read: Champions Trophy 2025: Pakistan’s Hosting Nightmare Begins with Empty Stadiums and Embarrassing Loss
Follow Fusion IAS
