The Hindu Editorial Discussion is crucial for UPSC CSE preparation, offering in-depth analysis of current affairs, government policies, and socio-economic issues. It enhances critical thinking, answer-writing skills, and interview preparation by providing diverse perspectives on national and international developments. Regular editorial reading helps aspirants develop a balanced viewpoint, improving their essay writing and General Studies papers.
1. The long and winding road of India-China relations
India-China relations have remained complex, shaped by historical conflicts, economic interdependence, and geopolitical developments. Despite efforts to normalize ties after the Galwan clashes in 2020, tensions persist along the Line of Actual Control (LAC). Recent diplomatic engagements, including Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri’s visit to China in January 2025, signal attempts at restoration, but concerns remain over border stability.
Recent Diplomatic Engagements
- India’s Outreach: Misri met Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi and other key officials, leading to agreements on resuming media exchanges, think tank dialogues, the Kailash Mansarovar Yatra, and bilateral flights in 2025.
- Context of Engagement: The timing coincides with Donald Trump’s re-election in the U.S., which has historically influenced China’s foreign policy decisions, including its approach toward India.
- China’s Strategic Calculations: China may be seeking to stabilize relations with India amidst economic concerns and shifting global dynamics.
Unresolved Border Issues
- Lack of Transparency on De-escalation: The Indian government has not provided clear updates on the status of de-escalation, demilitarization, and restoration of patrolling rights at key friction points such as Galwan, Depsang, Gogra, and Pangong Lake.
- China’s Narrative: Beijing continues to push for moving beyond the border standoff while India maintains that restoration of status quo ante is a precondition for broader cooperation.
Strategic Implications
- Geopolitical Considerations: The evolving India-China relationship is influenced by global realignments, including U.S.-China tensions, the Indo-Pacific strategy, and China’s internal economic slowdown.
- India’s Cautious Approach: Given past cyclical fluctuations in bilateral ties, India must balance engagement with strategic caution to safeguard its territorial and geopolitical interests.
Conclusion
While diplomatic efforts indicate a thaw in relations, unresolved border tensions and strategic distrust continue to shape India-China ties. Clarity on de-escalation and a firm stance on territorial integrity remain crucial for sustainable engagement. The evolving global landscape necessitates a pragmatic yet cautious approach in navigating India-China relations.
2. The transformation of Koraput’s tribal food basket
Koraput, a district in Odisha, is rich in biodiversity and home to a predominantly tribal population. However, despite multiple government schemes, poverty and undernutrition persist. According to NFHS-5 (2019-21), 43% of children under five are stunted, 33% are underweight, and over 50% of women are anaemic. A community-based model of nutrition literacy, implemented between 2013 and 2022, has helped improve dietary diversity and food security in the region.
Community-Based Nutrition Literacy Model
- MSSRF Initiative (2013-2022): The M.S. Swaminathan Research Foundation (MSSRF) launched a community-driven approach to nutrition awareness, focusing on agricultural diversification and improved hygiene.
- Sensitization Process: The initiative began by assessing the nutritional status of women, children, and adolescents. Villagers were engaged in discussions on balanced diets, dietary diversity, and nutrition-sensitive agriculture.
- Capacity Building:
- Selected men and women from villages underwent residential training on nutrition, sanitation, and diversified agriculture.
- The training emphasized collective decision-making, gender roles in nutrition, and sustainable farming practices.
Community-Driven Agricultural Transformation
- Dietary Diversity Awareness: The traditional perception of meals as a ‘dish count’ was replaced with an understanding of food groups and their nutritional value.
- Introduction of Nutritious Crops: Farmers integrated diverse crops like pulses, vegetables, and fruits in home gardens and fields. The number of cultivated crops increased from 4 to 9-11 varieties.
- Sustainable Farming Practices: Villagers adopted organic fertilizers, vermicomposting, and post-harvest value addition.
Social Mobilization and Collective Action
- Community Champions: Over 1,000 men and women were trained to spread nutrition awareness and agricultural techniques.
- Gender Inclusion: Women actively engaged with ASHA and Anganwadi workers, while men participated in joint agricultural decision-making with their spouses.
- Revival of Traditional Institutions:
- Community grain banks were re-established.
- Gram Sabha discussions led to better implementation of nutrition programs.
- A new Anganwadi center was sanctioned through collective village efforts.
Impact and Way Forward
- Improved Nutrition: Increased consumption of pulses, leafy vegetables, poultry, and wild foods.
- Sustainable Food Security: Home gardens remained operational for longer periods, ensuring year-round food availability.
- Community-Led Development: The initiative empowered local populations to demand entitlements, strengthen governance, and drive sustainable agricultural practices.
Conclusion
The transformation of Koraput’s tribal food basket highlights the power of community-driven initiatives in addressing undernutrition and food insecurity. The integration of nutrition literacy, diversified farming, and collective decision-making has set the foundation for sustainable development in the region. Scaling such models across other tribal and rural areas could significantly improve India’s nutrition security landscape.
3. Watering down: On water quality at Prayagraj
The Maha Kumbh Mela at Prayagraj attracts millions of devotees, making water quality in the Ganga a crucial public health concern. Despite large-scale monitoring by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), water pollution remains a significant issue. High faecal contamination, fluctuating biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), and dissolved oxygen (DO) levels highlight the river’s unfit condition for drinking and even bathing. Addressing Ganga pollution requires sustained long-term solutions rather than dismissing scientific data.
Water Pollution at Prayagraj
- Massive Influx of Devotees: Over 45 crore visitors have attended the Maha Kumbh Mela, making the Ganga a hotspot for microbial contamination.
- CPCB Monitoring Reports:
- On Makar Sankranti (January 14), faecal coliform levels at Sangam Ghat reached 11,000 units (4 times the permissible limit), while at Old Naini Bridge Ghat, it was 33,000 units.
- Water quality fluctuated, with some days recording lower contamination levels.
- The February 3 CPCB report to the National Green Tribunal (NGT) stated that water was not fit for bathing or drinking.
- Freshwater intrusion upstream occasionally improved organic pollution levels.
Recurring Water Quality Issues
- Not Limited to Kumbh Mela: CPCB’s routine monitoring shows that Ganga’s water quality fluctuates year-round due to variable water flow and dilution.
- Persistent Pollution Problem: Despite government efforts, the river remains unfit for direct consumption, indicating systemic pollution issues.
Challenges in Pollution Control
- Denialism in Governance: Uttar Pradesh CM Yogi Adityanath dismissed the scientific data as “baseless,” ignoring CPCB’s findings.
- National Mission for Clean Ganga (NMCG): The initiative aims at long-term restoration, but gaps in implementation persist.
- Need for Sustained Cleanup Efforts: Instead of short-term fixes during festivals, comprehensive waste management and pollution control measures are essential.
Way Forward
- Scientific Approach to River Cleaning: Instead of disregarding pollution concerns, authorities should integrate scientific solutions into river management.
- Strengthening NMCG Efforts: Continuous monitoring, wastewater treatment plants, and stricter pollution control policies are needed.
- Public Awareness and Community Participation: Encouraging responsible disposal of waste and promoting eco-friendly religious practices can help reduce contamination.
Conclusion
The Kumbh Mela serves as a reminder of the urgent need for effective water quality management in the Ganga. Dismissing scientific evidence undermines efforts to restore the river’s health. A data-driven, long-term approach is essential for ensuring clean and safe water, balancing spiritual traditions with environmental sustainability.
4. Is there a right to take offence?
The controversy surrounding the YouTube show India’s Got Latent has reignited the debate on free speech and criminal sanctions for offensive content. The Supreme Court’s interim protection for podcaster Ranveer Allahbadia highlights concerns about censorship and the selective enforcement of speech-related laws. The question remains: Is there a constitutional right to take offence, and should speech be criminalized based on subjective moral outrage?
Free Speech and the Right to Take Offence
- No Constitutional Right to Take Offence:
- Article 19(2) of the Indian Constitution provides reasonable restrictions on free speech but does not recognize offensive speech as a distinct category.
- Restrictions apply only to national security, public order, decency, and morality.
- Merely objectionable or unpalatable speech does not automatically qualify as a criminal offence.
- Legal Standards for Restricting Speech:
- Courts have moved from the restrictive Hicklin test (1964) to the community standards test (2014) to determine obscenity.
- The evolving judicial approach suggests that profanity alone does not constitute obscenity unless it meets a well-defined threshold.
Paternalism vs. Free Speech
- Should Speech Be Restricted for Moral Reasons?
- Gautam Patel: Speech can only be curtailed within the strict boundaries of Article 19(2). Executive overreach in restricting speech is unconstitutional.
- Dushyant Dave: Laws should regulate speech only when it incites violence. Arbitrary censorship is dangerous, especially when politicians engage in hate speech with impunity.
- Selective Enforcement of Speech Laws:
- Politicians routinely use divisive rhetoric, yet they evade legal consequences.
- Comedians and independent creators face multiple FIRs, highlighting a bias in law enforcement.
- A study by India Hate Lab reported a 74.4% rise in political hate speech in 2024, yet regulatory action remains absent.
Constitutional Morality and Public Sentiment
- Dushyant Dave: Constitutional morality should safeguard democratic values rather than cater to public outrage. Speech regulation must be based on clear legal standards, not fluctuating moral opinions.
- Gautam Patel: Speech restrictions should be defined by statutory law. Society has the right to criticize offensive speech but not to criminalize it arbitrarily.
Regulating Digital Content and Free Expression
- Concerns Over Censorship:
- The Broadcasting Services (Regulation) Bill aims to control digital content, raising fears of state overreach.
- Gautam Patel: Free speech must remain unrestricted to prevent authoritarian tendencies.
- Dushyant Dave: Selective enforcement of censorship laws disproportionately targets government critics.
Conclusion
The debate over free speech and offence highlights the need for consistent legal standards. Criminalizing content based on subjective moral outrage is a threat to democracy. While offensive speech can be criticized or boycotted, it should not be suppressed through arbitrary legal action. A free society thrives on debate and dissent, making the protection of speech fundamental to India’s democratic fabric.
Also Read: The Hindu Editorial Analysis: February 20, 2025
Disclaimer:
This analysis is based on the editorial content published in The Hindu and is intended solely for informational and educational purposes. The views, opinions, and interpretations expressed herein are those of the author of original article. Readers are encouraged to refer to the original article for complete context and to exercise their own judgment while interpreting the analysis. The analysis does not constitute professional advice or endorsement of any political, economic, or social perspective.
Follow Fusion IAS